Pet food brand

C

Black Cat

C Average score: 57/100 (Average)

Discover the 2 Black Cat products graded A to E by PetFoodRate. Our independent analysis covers protein quality, nutritional value, absence of undesirables, label transparency, and species adaptability.

In short

Black Cat averages 57/100 (C) across 2 graded products, 0 of them A or B. It is strongest on "Few undesirables" and weakest on "Species fit". Top-rated product: Black Cat Peanut Butter (57/100).

By Theo Blanchard · reviewed by Max Kowalski · updated June 2026 · independent grading, no sponsorship

A
0
B
0
C
2
D
0
E
0

The Black Cat profile across 5 criteria

Average of the A–E sub-scores across the 2 graded Black Cat products. The brand is strongest on "Few undesirables" and weakest on "Species fit".

  • Protein quality D · 45/100
  • Nutritional balance C · 60/100
  • Few undesirables B · 75/100
  • Ingredient transparency C · 60/100
  • Species fit D · 45/100

All Black Cat products graded

#1
C 57
Peanut Butter
dry food cats
#2
C 57
Smooth Peanut Butter
dry food cats

Our verdict on Black Cat

Black Cat offers 2 products in our database, covering 1 food type and 1 species. The brand average score is 57/100, a grade C (Average). This score evolves whenever we add products or update our methodology.

Understand the grade

Keep exploring

All brands Compare pet food brands Best by category Top by species and type Compare 2 products Side by side, grade by grade

Frequently asked questions

How many Black Cat products are rated?

2 Black Cat products are rated by PetFoodRate, with an average score of 57/100 (C).

What is the best Black Cat product?

The highest-rated Black Cat product in our database is Black Cat Peanut Butter (grade C).

Is Black Cat a good brand?

Based on its rated products, Black Cat averages 57/100, i.e. C on our A to E scale. Quality can vary across ranges: check each product's grade.

How does PetFoodRate rate brands?

Each product is graded A to E on five axes (proteins, nutrition, undesirables, transparency, suitability). A brand's score is the average of its products; only brands with at least 10 rated products enter the comparative ranking.